Hemingway uses characterization through dialogue and symbolism to characterize the relationship between the two characters as distant, causing them to be unable to communicate effectively.
Through their dialogue, it becomes apparent that the man and the girl are distant and unable to communicate well. When the man states, "The beer's nice and cool," the girl replies by saying "It's lovely" (Hemingway). This boring dialogue exemplifies the relationship between the man and the girl because they talk about the very basic and boring observations that they make from around them instead of talking about the real issues that they have. Their conversation barely skims the surface of their issues, as they have many to work out about the "simple"procedure and its effect on the rest of their lives.
Through symbolism, Hemingway characterizes the relationship between the two characters as distant because it lacks necessary communication skills. There are many examples of symbolism in this text, a few of them being suitcases, hills, railroads, Jig, and drinking. The suitcases are both literal and metaphorical baggage, and their transportation from light area to dark area creates a rift between the man and the girl. The man decides where the suitcases go but the girl "was sitting at the table," and did not move when he changed the location of the suitcases (Hemingway). The light and the dark also symbolized the rift between the two, as neither felt comfortable discussing their actual views on the procedure. The girl seemed unable to do anything but agree with the man about where to place the bags, symbolizing that Hemingway characterizes the two characters as distant because they are unable to communicate effectively.
Monday, September 29, 2014
Wednesday, September 24, 2014
I Stand Here Ironing Q2 Response
Olsen's use of a first person point of view and a pitiful tone characterize the narrator's view that motherhood requires balancing, and that children can grow up even without a perfect childhood.
Through first person point of view Olsen emphasizes that she has done all she can to help Emily, and that she cane be a successful adult even though she is not perfect. As the the mother states, "she is a child of her age, of depression, of war, of fear" (Olsen 271). There were many aspects of Emily's childhood that were beyond the control of her mother and her mother feels badly about that, but also knows that she could not have fixed that. She admits she could have done more to not be distracted, but the mother also states that while some think Emily has not reached her full potential, that no one really does. The mother believes that Emily will be able to function alright even though her childhood was not great.
Olsen argues that children can grow up alright even if they do not have a great childhood and that motherhood is a balancing act, through her use of a pitiful tone. This tone begins early in the text, and continues on throughout. This starts when the mother says she used to be a beautiful baby, but no one thinks she is anymore. It continues with the mother's comment that she "used to try to hold and love her after she came back, but her body would stay stiff, and after a while she'd push away" (Olsen 269). Emily is unable to be loved, and this creates a pitiful tone because of the image it creates of a little girl who is yearning to be accepted, but can not be. Olsen uses a pitiful tone to show that motherhood is a balancing act, and that children can grow up even without a perfect childhood.
Through first person point of view Olsen emphasizes that she has done all she can to help Emily, and that she cane be a successful adult even though she is not perfect. As the the mother states, "she is a child of her age, of depression, of war, of fear" (Olsen 271). There were many aspects of Emily's childhood that were beyond the control of her mother and her mother feels badly about that, but also knows that she could not have fixed that. She admits she could have done more to not be distracted, but the mother also states that while some think Emily has not reached her full potential, that no one really does. The mother believes that Emily will be able to function alright even though her childhood was not great.
Olsen argues that children can grow up alright even if they do not have a great childhood and that motherhood is a balancing act, through her use of a pitiful tone. This tone begins early in the text, and continues on throughout. This starts when the mother says she used to be a beautiful baby, but no one thinks she is anymore. It continues with the mother's comment that she "used to try to hold and love her after she came back, but her body would stay stiff, and after a while she'd push away" (Olsen 269). Emily is unable to be loved, and this creates a pitiful tone because of the image it creates of a little girl who is yearning to be accepted, but can not be. Olsen uses a pitiful tone to show that motherhood is a balancing act, and that children can grow up even without a perfect childhood.
Sunday, September 21, 2014
Cathedral Questions
Question One:
The narrator reveals much more information about his wife than he does about himself. He begins the story by describing how his wife met a blind man, and the formation and strengthening of their relationship. The narrator describes his wife's relationship with her previous husband, a member of the military, while still describing her long distance friendship with the blind man. Apart from the narrator occasionally describing the woman as "my wife" and saying "I knew" or "I looked forward to," he seemed to be describing the story as an outsider (Carver 1079). The audience barely knew any personal information about him in the beginning.
Question Two:
The narrator's combination of personal thoughts and descriptions of the current action create a unique view of Robert. He does not feel comfortable speaking with him, as the only topics of conversation he can come up with revolve around being able to see. He describes his thoughts that he "wanted to say something else, small-talk, about the scenic ride along the Hudson" (Carver 1082). He feels secretly ashamed as he knows that Robert can not answer this, but can not think of much else to say. When Robert tries to lighten the mood with talking about Scotch, the narrator brushes off his jokes.
Question Three:
In the beginning of this text the narrator had never interacted with a blind person, so he somewhat understandably did not know how to act. He pitied Robert's wife, as she "never saw herself as she was seen in the eyes of her loved one" (Carver 1081). This seems so sad and almost pathetic to him, as he does not understand until later in the text the amount of passion that Robert posseses. Towards the end of this story the narrator realizes Robert does not know what a cathedral is, so they draw one together. With both of their eyes closed and Robert's hand on the narrator's, the narrator finally is able to understand how Robert functions. Although Robert is unable to see he still processes information well and feels his way through life, instead of having to see everything.
Question Five:
Carver withholds the specific realization of the epiphany at the end of the text to show how abstract the feeling the narrator had really was. As the narrator described, "I was in my house. I knew that. But I didn't feel like I was inside anything" (Carver 1089). The narrator never specifically tells the audience what this feeling he is feeling is. He clearly feels enlightened by his experience with Robert, and it seems to be a positive change. Many know how that feeling of pure epiphany feels, and it would be extremely difficult to capture that in the context of this story. Carver leaves the conclusion out in order to force the reader to reflect on this feeling in their own lives, instead of it being given to them.
Question Six:
Carver does not seem to judge the narrator and his wife. They tend to overindulge, smoke too much, and are not very close to each other. While it may be easy to judge their situation, Carver does not seem to. When describing the narrator's drug use he states, "I asked him to smoke some dope with me" (Carver 1085). The narrator's thoughts and actions about the whole situation seem very casual. The narrator is much different at the end of the text, however, when he has his epiphany. He no longer is just gliding by, but he feels raw emotion for the first time in what can be imagined as a while. Carver illuminates the cultural norm of today's busy society by first seeming to agree with the nonchalance of the narrator using drugs. He then clearly challenges the actions of modern day culture by showing the epiphany as much more important, and as a type of awakening from the narrator's passerby attitude.
The narrator reveals much more information about his wife than he does about himself. He begins the story by describing how his wife met a blind man, and the formation and strengthening of their relationship. The narrator describes his wife's relationship with her previous husband, a member of the military, while still describing her long distance friendship with the blind man. Apart from the narrator occasionally describing the woman as "my wife" and saying "I knew" or "I looked forward to," he seemed to be describing the story as an outsider (Carver 1079). The audience barely knew any personal information about him in the beginning.
Question Two:
The narrator's combination of personal thoughts and descriptions of the current action create a unique view of Robert. He does not feel comfortable speaking with him, as the only topics of conversation he can come up with revolve around being able to see. He describes his thoughts that he "wanted to say something else, small-talk, about the scenic ride along the Hudson" (Carver 1082). He feels secretly ashamed as he knows that Robert can not answer this, but can not think of much else to say. When Robert tries to lighten the mood with talking about Scotch, the narrator brushes off his jokes.
Question Three:
In the beginning of this text the narrator had never interacted with a blind person, so he somewhat understandably did not know how to act. He pitied Robert's wife, as she "never saw herself as she was seen in the eyes of her loved one" (Carver 1081). This seems so sad and almost pathetic to him, as he does not understand until later in the text the amount of passion that Robert posseses. Towards the end of this story the narrator realizes Robert does not know what a cathedral is, so they draw one together. With both of their eyes closed and Robert's hand on the narrator's, the narrator finally is able to understand how Robert functions. Although Robert is unable to see he still processes information well and feels his way through life, instead of having to see everything.
Question Five:
Carver withholds the specific realization of the epiphany at the end of the text to show how abstract the feeling the narrator had really was. As the narrator described, "I was in my house. I knew that. But I didn't feel like I was inside anything" (Carver 1089). The narrator never specifically tells the audience what this feeling he is feeling is. He clearly feels enlightened by his experience with Robert, and it seems to be a positive change. Many know how that feeling of pure epiphany feels, and it would be extremely difficult to capture that in the context of this story. Carver leaves the conclusion out in order to force the reader to reflect on this feeling in their own lives, instead of it being given to them.
Question Six:
Carver does not seem to judge the narrator and his wife. They tend to overindulge, smoke too much, and are not very close to each other. While it may be easy to judge their situation, Carver does not seem to. When describing the narrator's drug use he states, "I asked him to smoke some dope with me" (Carver 1085). The narrator's thoughts and actions about the whole situation seem very casual. The narrator is much different at the end of the text, however, when he has his epiphany. He no longer is just gliding by, but he feels raw emotion for the first time in what can be imagined as a while. Carver illuminates the cultural norm of today's busy society by first seeming to agree with the nonchalance of the narrator using drugs. He then clearly challenges the actions of modern day culture by showing the epiphany as much more important, and as a type of awakening from the narrator's passerby attitude.
Friday, September 19, 2014
"Where are you going, where have you been" Literary Analysis
In "Where are you going, where have you been," Joyce Carol Oates tells the story of a teenager girls who enjoys rebelling against her parents. Through Arnold Friend's proposition to become lovers and threats if they do not become anything, Oates testifies that the naive and self-centered attitude of teenage girls allows them to be taken advantage of, as seen through characterization.
Connie can be described as a stereotypical teenager girl who is focused only on herself and her own issues. This drives a wedge between her and her family, as they can no longer relate to each other. Connie's mother scolds her as she had a "habit of craning her neck to glance into mirrors, or checking other people's faces to make sure her own was all right" (Oates 468). She is very self-centered and only really cares about herself, even if it makes others look poorly. Although her parents are probably aware of it, she also enjoys sneaking out of the house to go out with her friends. While at a local restaurant, she sees a young man who mouths to her "Gonna get you, baby" and yet she thinks very little of it (Oates 469). She is very naive in this situation because she is not in the slightest worried about this man who was staring at her and mouthing creepy phrases.
Connie slightly enjoys it when Arnold Friend first appears at her house while she was home alone. Even when he says he knows divid detail about her family he has never met, and detail that she does not even know, she is only slightly offput. It is not until she realizes that "he wasn't a kid, he was much older- thirty, maybe more" through his odd assemblage of character traits (Oates 474). It takes her a long time to get to this point of recognizing that he is not who he is saying that he is, and even when she does realize this, she does not know how to act. Her naive spirit allow her to be taken advantage by Arnold because she does not understand how to react to him, and eventually agrees to leave with him. Joyce Carol Oates' purpose in writing this short story is to argue, through characterization, that the self-centered and naive attitude of teenager girls allows them to be taken advantage of.
Wednesday, September 17, 2014
The Yellow Wallpaper Literary Analysis
The Yellow Wallpaper Literary Analysis
In "The Yellow Wallpaper," Charlotte Perkins Gilman tells the story of a young woman who feels confused and paranoid about the yellow wallpaper in her house. Through her the husband's attempts to shelter her and her interactions with the wallpaper, Gilman emphasizes that women in 1892 feel suffocated by the men in their lives and that the pursuit of liberation can drive them crazy, as demonstrated through the use of setting in the text.
In the beginning of the text, the house that this family leases feels like a normal home. There are beautiful gardens, large airy rooms, and plenty of space. However, the description of the house takes on a different meaning when the narrator describes a room she thinks was once a play room for small children. This room has yellow wallpaper and a "great immovable bead- it is nailed down" (Gilman 96). This yellow wallpapered room not only has furniture nailed to the ground, but it also has bars over the windows and part of the wallpaper has been scratched off. The narrator wants to spend a considerable amount of time in this room, however her husband initially does not let her because even though she thinks it is a play room, it more closely resembles an area to keep the mentally ill. This aggravates her because she finds the intricate wallpaper pattern to be intriguing.
As the text progresses, the wife becomes increasingly mentally unstable. Her husband tries to keep her in bed and resting for more of the day, but she has trouble thinking about anything other than the wallpaper; even her family crosses her mind less and less. The narrator sees a woman inside the wallpaper and she spends the majority of her time trying to figure out the mystery of it, which her setting allows her to do. After her husband passes out, she circles the room following the lady in the wall. She describes him as "right across my path by the wall, so that I had to creep over him every time" (Gilman 288-289). Even though she is at the point of the most mental instability, she finally feels free from her husband. She is literally stepping over him, instead of him usually walking all over her in the metaphorical sense. She gains control, but it deprives her of her sanity in the process. In order to break free of the tight grasp of men in 1892, Gilman argues that a woman will become crazy.
In "The Yellow Wallpaper," Charlotte Perkins Gilman tells the story of a young woman who feels confused and paranoid about the yellow wallpaper in her house. Through her the husband's attempts to shelter her and her interactions with the wallpaper, Gilman emphasizes that women in 1892 feel suffocated by the men in their lives and that the pursuit of liberation can drive them crazy, as demonstrated through the use of setting in the text.
In the beginning of the text, the house that this family leases feels like a normal home. There are beautiful gardens, large airy rooms, and plenty of space. However, the description of the house takes on a different meaning when the narrator describes a room she thinks was once a play room for small children. This room has yellow wallpaper and a "great immovable bead- it is nailed down" (Gilman 96). This yellow wallpapered room not only has furniture nailed to the ground, but it also has bars over the windows and part of the wallpaper has been scratched off. The narrator wants to spend a considerable amount of time in this room, however her husband initially does not let her because even though she thinks it is a play room, it more closely resembles an area to keep the mentally ill. This aggravates her because she finds the intricate wallpaper pattern to be intriguing.
As the text progresses, the wife becomes increasingly mentally unstable. Her husband tries to keep her in bed and resting for more of the day, but she has trouble thinking about anything other than the wallpaper; even her family crosses her mind less and less. The narrator sees a woman inside the wallpaper and she spends the majority of her time trying to figure out the mystery of it, which her setting allows her to do. After her husband passes out, she circles the room following the lady in the wall. She describes him as "right across my path by the wall, so that I had to creep over him every time" (Gilman 288-289). Even though she is at the point of the most mental instability, she finally feels free from her husband. She is literally stepping over him, instead of him usually walking all over her in the metaphorical sense. She gains control, but it deprives her of her sanity in the process. In order to break free of the tight grasp of men in 1892, Gilman argues that a woman will become crazy.
Tuesday, September 16, 2014
The Yellow Wallpaper Questions
Question One:
The narrator in The Yellow Wallpaper changed throughout the text; she began the text as a seemingly normal character. By the end, however, she became increasingly paranoid with the yellow wallpaper. Towards the beginning, she justified her sanity with the fact that her husband and her brother are both doctors and they would have told her if they actually thought she was crazy. Around the same time, she only dislikes the wallpaper. She asks her husband to take it down because it makes her unhappy, but he does not because their lease is up in less than three months. As the text progresses, she makes more and more "observations" about the wallpaper. At the end of the text, she refused to let her husband in the locked house in order to keep the wallpaper and the creepy woman inside. She can feel her lifestyle changing, as she sleeps during the day but not at night. Also, she mentions her baby less and less throughout the text because her priorities change from her family, to watching the wallpaper.
Question Two:
Although the narrator describes the yellow wallpapered room as being a former nursery and area where children played, there are discrepancies with this idea. The narrator states that the wallpaper is peeling and there are bars on the windows. She believes that the bars were to keep the children from falling out and the walls were worn down by the playing of children. However it seems more like this room was used to hold crazy people. The barred windows suggest that they had to prevent them from escaping, and these people peeled the wallpaper just like the narrator did near the end of the text. This discrepancy helps the audience to realize that the narrator is quickly becoming crazier. The reader or the audience may not have realized this in the beginning, but it is clearly seent that her mind is deteriorating. She no longer sees the world in a more rational and normal view, but she instead fully believes her own ideas on the situation even when they appear to be wrong. The narrator lost her ability to understand others, as seen by her descriptions of this room.
Question Four:
In lines 96 through 104, Charlotte Perkins Gilman's syntax mirrors the pattern on the wallpaper and suggests the narrator's agitation. The pattern of the wallpaper is becoming increasingly abstract and difficult to understand for the narrator. When she first looked at the wallpaper she did not like the pattern, but she did not find it extremely captivating or confusing. In lines 96 through 104, the narrator begins to see the complexity in the wallpaper that she spends so much time trying to understand in later parts of the text. The syntax of the sentences show the confusion and agitation that the narrator feels, and she becomes agitated by the fact that the wallpaper is so confusing because she can not just instantly comprehend the intricacies of this yellow wallpaper.
The narrator in The Yellow Wallpaper changed throughout the text; she began the text as a seemingly normal character. By the end, however, she became increasingly paranoid with the yellow wallpaper. Towards the beginning, she justified her sanity with the fact that her husband and her brother are both doctors and they would have told her if they actually thought she was crazy. Around the same time, she only dislikes the wallpaper. She asks her husband to take it down because it makes her unhappy, but he does not because their lease is up in less than three months. As the text progresses, she makes more and more "observations" about the wallpaper. At the end of the text, she refused to let her husband in the locked house in order to keep the wallpaper and the creepy woman inside. She can feel her lifestyle changing, as she sleeps during the day but not at night. Also, she mentions her baby less and less throughout the text because her priorities change from her family, to watching the wallpaper.
Question Two:
Although the narrator describes the yellow wallpapered room as being a former nursery and area where children played, there are discrepancies with this idea. The narrator states that the wallpaper is peeling and there are bars on the windows. She believes that the bars were to keep the children from falling out and the walls were worn down by the playing of children. However it seems more like this room was used to hold crazy people. The barred windows suggest that they had to prevent them from escaping, and these people peeled the wallpaper just like the narrator did near the end of the text. This discrepancy helps the audience to realize that the narrator is quickly becoming crazier. The reader or the audience may not have realized this in the beginning, but it is clearly seent that her mind is deteriorating. She no longer sees the world in a more rational and normal view, but she instead fully believes her own ideas on the situation even when they appear to be wrong. The narrator lost her ability to understand others, as seen by her descriptions of this room.
Question Four:
In lines 96 through 104, Charlotte Perkins Gilman's syntax mirrors the pattern on the wallpaper and suggests the narrator's agitation. The pattern of the wallpaper is becoming increasingly abstract and difficult to understand for the narrator. When she first looked at the wallpaper she did not like the pattern, but she did not find it extremely captivating or confusing. In lines 96 through 104, the narrator begins to see the complexity in the wallpaper that she spends so much time trying to understand in later parts of the text. The syntax of the sentences show the confusion and agitation that the narrator feels, and she becomes agitated by the fact that the wallpaper is so confusing because she can not just instantly comprehend the intricacies of this yellow wallpaper.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
