Wednesday, October 29, 2014

The Awakening Critical Response

The citicism George M. Spanger presents on The Awakening states that the inconsistencies in Edna's character at the end of the novel prevents it from being an impactful masterpiece; instead it becomes an ordinary, sentimental novel that contradicts the previous characterization of strong women.  Spanger states, "Its great fault is inconsistent characterization, which asks the reader to accept a different and diminished Edna from the one developed so impressively before."  Throughout the novel Edna is chracterized as strong and independent as she resists the pressure of Creole society, until she kills herself at the conclusion.  This contradicts almost everything she has done in the past, which is unsettling to the reader for her character to make such a sudden transformation and then die before it can be explained.  Spanger also states that "the painful failure of vision... implicit in the change prevents a very good, very interesting novel from being the extraordinary masterpiece some commentators have claimed it is."  Due to the nature of the ending, Spanger does not believe the novel is a masterpiece anymore.  He argues that even though the rest of the novel had masterpiece potential, that was lost by the ending.
The presented argument is valid because the ending of the novel does not continue the same themes that were presented throughout the rest of the novel.  He is correct in saying that the themes change, as it may be difficult to discern any previous intention by Edna to kill herself and have a sudden change of heart.  She said to Adele Ratignolle that she would "give up the unessential, but she would never sacrifice herself for her children" (155).  This contradicts her behavior right before she dies, as she expresses that she would do anything for her children to be happy.  Spanger's argument clearly has validity to it, but he is missing an important part.  This novel received such harsh reviews and was not oringially printed by many publishers; people found the novel to be an outrage because it challenged the ideas of that time.  This protest was even with this romanticized ending, and so as a result of the time, Chopin was forced to have an ending of this type in order for it to be printed.  Chances are that if she had the strong, powerful ending that coincided with the rest of the novel, then no one would have printed it.  Chopin realized that she needed to please the public with the ending if she wanted the message of the rest of it to be spread.

No comments:

Post a Comment